Thank you to everyone that took part in the survey - here are the results
346 people took part in our survey to assess the impact of the 100% council tax premium for second homes. The survey has provided strong evidence that the policy is having significant unintended social and economic consequences, with limited confidence that its stated objectives are being achieved. It is already influencing behaviour, particularly in reduced spending, weakened community cohesion, and reconsideration of long-term engagement with the island.
89% of respondents rated the impact of the policy as negative.
57% believed it will result in fewer new permanent residents.
Only 12% agreed it will free up homes for working families.
83% of second homeowners have reduced their spending on the island.
The total negative impact on the island’s economy is likely to be more than £450,000. The island has a total economic output of just £12.9 million.
We will share the results with North Ayrshire Council for their Cabinet meeting in June which will assess the implementation of the policy. The survey results will supplement North Ayrshire Council's own monitoring which will report on "movement in property status”.
